Smart Prop Trader
Closed. Operations ceased 29 December 2024 and its domain now redirects to an unrelated broker with no explanation. Listed so that anyone who finds an old review of it knows the firm no longer exists.
The redirect is the finding, and it very nearly went unrecorded. A saved page keeps the address we asked for at the top, so smartproptrader.com would have been filed as this firm’s own home page while serving somebody else’s — a broker called FXnity, which never mentions Smart Prop Trader. Snapshots now write the destination on the status line when the host changes, which is what makes this citable at all.
Crossed one of the seven hard bars. Open the row and it names which one, with the mechanism spelled out. This is not a low grade — no quantity of virtue elsewhere buys it off, which is why it carries no rank at all.
Disqualified for
The firm has closed
It stopped operating, and the date is on the row. Kept in the register rather than deleted so that somebody searching the name lands on when it closed instead of on an archived sales page. This is not a judgement of how it treated traders while it ran — several of these paid out to the end and shut down when a platform licence was withdrawn.
What they published
This address no longer answers. What came back is saved with the page.
Scorecard
12Trails, but only freezes far above your starting balance
No entity named, or the licence belongs to someone else
Workable, but a cap or a waiting period bites
Every page we read agreed with every other
Short history, or a sharply polarised review profile
Each axis is scored 0–5 against a published scale. The line under each bar is the rung this firm landed on — not our summary of it, the scale entry itself.
The score is published anyway, because it is the honest picture: a firm can be strong on four axes and still be disqualified on one mechanism. A disqualifier is not a low grade — it is a rule we will not trade under at any price.
Trustpilot
We read its rules and scored it, but did not price every plan it sells individually.